1. Home
  2. New York
  3. Erie County
  4. Elma

Old Mill Cir, Elma, NY Property Records

Erie County and Elma Town property records for 28 addresses on Old Mill Cir, Elma, NY · Last verified August 2026

Old Mill Cir Highlights

Properties 28
Median Sale Price $258,000
Deeds and Mortgages on File 29
Median Price per Sqft $175
Owner Occupied 79%
Median Annual Tax Bill $2,072
Median Year Built 1989
Median Ownership Tenure 7 years

Properties on Old Mill Cir

Owner names and prior sale amounts shown locked below are available instantly with a free trial.

1 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1988 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$167,000Oct 2019 $1,8522025 Amount on Record May 2015 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

2 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,176 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$158,000Nov 2017 $4,6572025 Amount on Record Jan 1998 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

3 Old Mill Cir

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$235,000Nov 2024 $1,2432025 Amount on Record Dec 2012 1 Name on Record AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

4 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$170,000Jan 2020 $1,8522025 Amount on Record Apr 2013 2 Names on Record Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

5 Old Mill Cir

3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,788 sqft · built 1991 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$92,900Nov 1997 $2,0722025 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

6 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,788 sqft · built 1992 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$295,000Jun 2025 $11,9672025 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

7 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,427 sqft · built 1992 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$315,000Oct 2025 $5,5732025 Amount on Record Nov 2024 1 Name on Record Assessor + 3 DocumentsUpdated Jun 2026

View Property Record

8 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,788 sqft · built 1991 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$170,000Dec 2015 $2,0722025 Amount on Record Nov 1996 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

9 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$154,500Feb 2019 $4,6442025 Amount on Record Sep 2015 1 Name on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

10 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$190,000Jul 2022 $1,8522025 Amount on Record Oct 2014 1 Name on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

11 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,176 sqft · built 1988 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$7,6032025 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

12 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,176 sqft · built 1988 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$157,500Jan 2019 $1,8202025 Amount on Record Nov 2006 1 Name on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

13 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,176 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$156,900Feb 2010 $4,5412025 Amount on Record May 2004 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

14 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,176 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$133,000Jan 2005 $4,8332025 1 Name on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

15 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$175,000Aug 2019 $7,0942025 Amount on Record Oct 2009 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

16 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,176 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$1,8202025 1 Name on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

17 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,788 sqft · built 1993 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$350,000Oct 2025 $9,1762025 Amount on Record Jun 2007 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Jul 2026

View Property Record

18 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,788 sqft · built 1993 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$192,000Jul 2014 $2,0722025 Amount on Record Jun 2000 1 Name on Record AssessorUpdated Jul 2026

View Property Record

19 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,427 sqft · built 1993 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$265,000Nov 2022 $1,9622025 Amount on Record Aug 2004 1 Name on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

20 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,788 sqft · built 1993 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$258,000Dec 2022 $2,0722025 Amount on Record Aug 1995 2 Names on Record Assessor + 3 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

21 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$162,500Sep 2017 $1,5702025 Amount on Record Mar 2013 2 Names on Record Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

22 Old Mill Cir

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$227,000Sep 2024 $4,8802025 Amount on Record May 2014 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

23 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$135,000Jul 2009 $1,8522025 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

24 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2 ba · 1,296 sqft · built 1989 · 0.051 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$117,000May 1998 $7,9012025 Amount on Record Jun 1997 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

25 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,788 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$199,000Mar 2017 $2,0722025 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

26 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,394 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$174,000Oct 2009 $4,2942025 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

27 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,788 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$249,000Feb 2023 $2,0722025 Amount on Record Sep 2007 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

28 Old Mill Cir

2 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,302 sqft · built 1989 · 0.041 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$154,000Nov 2013 $5,2322025 Amount on Record Oct 2009 2 Names on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated May 2026

View Property Record

Wildfire Risk on Old Mill Cir

Source: USDA Forest Service Wildfire Risk to Communities · 2nd edition (2024), fuels as of 2020

Wildfire RiskLow
this street's cells rank above 20% of the US · above 55% of New York
Wildfire LikelihoodAbout 1 in 8,333 per year
ExposureIndirect
0 of 1 cells directly exposed · 1 adjoin burnable vegetation

Property Records in Nearby Streets