1. Home
  2. New York
  3. Suffolk County
  4. West Islip

W 5th St, West Islip, NY Property Records

Suffolk County and Islip Town property records for 28 addresses on W 5th St, West Islip, NY · Last verified October 2026

W 5th St Highlights

Properties 28
Median Sale Price $475,000
Deeds and Mortgages on File 21
Median Price per Sqft $463
Owner Occupied 89%
Median Annual Tax Bill $11,763
Median Year Built 1960
Median Ownership Tenure 19 years

Properties on W 5th St

Owner names and prior sale amounts shown locked below are available instantly with a free trial.

5th W 5th St

0.13 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
Owner on Record AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

118 W 5th St

0.3 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$550,000May 2024 $9,9272024 Amount on Record Mar 2003 Owner on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

123 W 5th St

0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$164,500May 1996 $11,7632024 Owner on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

130 W 5th St

0.18 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
—Nov 2013 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

131 W 5th St

0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$13,9492024 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 4 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

140 W 5th St

0.269 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
Owner on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

141 W 5th St

0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

205 W 5th St

0.28 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$439,000Nov 2003 $13,1892024 Amount on Record Sep 2002 Owner on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

210 W 5th St

0.18 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$465,000Dec 2007 Owner on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Oct 2026

View Property Record

215 W 5th St

0.169 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$245,000Mar 2002 $9,9552024 Amount on Record Aug 1994 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 4 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

226 W 5th St

0.16 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$334,000Aug 2018 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

229 W 5th St

0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$234,000Sep 2002 Amount on Record Oct 1995 Owner on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

232 W 5th St

0.16 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
—Feb 1998 Owner on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Oct 2026

View Property Record

236 W 5th St

0.18 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
Owner on Record AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

239 W 5th St

1,025 sqft · built 1962 · 0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$475,000May 2021 $12,7922024 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

242 W 5th St

0.18 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
Owner on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

244 W 5th St

0.089 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$255,500Aug 2002 Owner on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

246 W 5th St

0.089 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$197,000Dec 2018 —Mar 1995 Owner on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

255 W 5th St

1,053 sqft · built 1959 · 0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
Owner on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Oct 2026

View Property Record

260 W 5th St

1,311 sqft · built 1959 · 0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$689,000May 2025 Amount on Record Nov 2024 Owner on Record Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

265 W 5th St

0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$245,000Oct 2001 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

305 W 5th St

0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
Owner on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

310 W 5th St

0.18 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

314 W 5th St

0.18 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$205,000Jul 2013 $10,9962024 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

318 W 5th St

0.18 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

333 W 5th St

0.269 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$108,500Apr 1997 $10,7142024 Amount on Record Aug 1993 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Oct 2026

View Property Record

339 W 5th St

2,185 sqft · built 1960 · 0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$540,000Sep 2021 $13,3322024 Amount on Record Jun 2019 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Oct 2026

View Property Record

357 W 5th St

0.23 acres

Last Sale Tax Bill Prior Sale Owner Records
$355,000Aug 2005 $10,3772024 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied AssessorUpdated Aug 2026

View Property Record

Property Records in Nearby Streets