5850 E 91st St, Indianapolis, IN 46250 Property Records

Marion County property record for 5850 E 91st St, Indianapolis, IN 46250

Property Summary

Property Type	Single Family Home
Details	1.5 ba · 2,320 sqft · built 1975
Lot Size	0.358 acres (15,594 sqft)
Owner	2 Individual Names on File
Last Sale	$445,550 (Aug 2022)
Tax Bill	$3,420 (2024)
Deeds & Mortgages	Aug 2022 Mortgage Nov 2019 Loan Modification
Flood Zone	Zone X (minimal risk)
APN	`49-02-15-108-058.000-400`

Property Details

APN / Parcel Number

Primary APN	`49-02-15-108-058.000-400`
Alternative APN	`4020212`

Interior

Full Baths	1.5 Baths
Half Baths	1 Half Bath
Plumbing Fixtures	10 Plumbing Fixtures
Stories	2 Stories
Building Area	2,320 sqft Living Area
Gross Area	3,920 sqft
1st Floor Area	2,320 sqft
Upper Floors Area	1,184 sqft
Basement Area	1,072 sqft
Fireplaces	1 Fireplace
Fireplace	Fireplace

Exterior

Year Built	Built 1975
Effective Year Built	Effective 1975
Construction Type	Masonry / Concrete Block
Roof Material	Asphalt
Lot Area	15,594 sqft (0.358 acres)
Lot Dimensions	188 ft deep x 83 ft wide
Garage Type	Attached
Garage Area	528 sqft
Parking Spaces	2 Parking Spaces

Utilities, Heating & Cooling

Cooling System	Central
Heating System	Central

Location & Zoning

Street Address	5850 E 91ST ST
City	INDIANAPOLIS
State	IN
Zip	46250-1378
Property Category	Residential
Property Type	Residential > Single Family > Home
Legal Description	CASTLEWOOD ADDITION SEC 1 L41
Legal Subdivision	CASTLEWOOD ADDITION SEC 1
Legal Lot Number	41
Jurisdiction	MARION IN
Township / Civil Division	LAWRENCE
Census Block Group	5
Census Block	5001
Census Tract	330103

Owner

5850 E 91st St is owned and occupied by two individuals who bought it in August 2022.

Source: Marion County records, as of March 16, 2026

Owner of Record	2 Individual Names on File
Mailing Address	5850 E 91ST ST, INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46250-1378
Occupancy	Owner Occupied
Owner Type	Individual
Vesting	Husband and Wife

Owner names and exact recorded amounts are on file and can be viewed instantly on this page with a free 10-day trial.

Deeds, Mortgages & Sale History

Date	Document
Aug 11, 2022	Warranty Deed, Transfer · Conventional Mortgage TUCKER MORTGAGE LLC
Nov 30, 2019	Loan Modification, Mortgage MIDFIRST BK

Assessor's Deed Record

Deed Names	2 Names on Deed
Last Sale	Aug 11, 2022 · Amount on File
Deed Sale	Aug 11, 2022 · Amount on File
Prior Sale	Aug 31, 2010 · Amount on File
Deed Document Number	202290426
Record Updated	Sep 20, 2026

August 2022: Warranty Deed, Transfer

Document Type	Warranty Deed
Jurisdiction	MARION IN
Recording Date	Aug 11, 2022
Property Address	5850 E 91ST ST, INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46250-1378
Document Number	0000090426
Map Reference	IN 7443109
Instrument Date	Jul 6, 2022
Instrument	A202200090426
Transaction Type	Transfer
Record Updated	Jun 23, 2026
Title Company	ATA NATIONAL TITLE

Transaction

Tax	$0.00
Additional	Arm's Length

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

Name	Verified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Address	5850 E 91ST ST, INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46250-1378
Investor	Possibly a Property Investor

Mortgage

Document Number	0000090427
Date	Aug 11, 2022
Instrument	A202200090427

Lender

Name	TUCKER MORTGAGE LLC
Type	Mortgage Company

Agreement

Type	Conventional Mortgage
Amount	Amount on Record
Term	360 Months
Due	Aug 1, 2052

Interest

Rate Type	Adjustable Rate
Adjustable	Adjustable Rate Rider
Type Change Date	Aug 1, 2037
Change Frequency	6 Months
Min Rate At Change	3%
Max Rate At Change	10.2%
Index	Other
Margin	3

November 2019: Loan Modification, Mortgage

Document Type	Loan Modification
Jurisdiction	MARION IN
Property Address	5850 E 91ST ST, INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46250-1378
Document Number	0000125888
Instrument Date	Nov 30, 2019
Transaction Type	Mortgage
Record Updated	Jan 7, 2020
Title Company	FIRST AMERICAN TITLE

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Address	5850 E 91ST ST INDIANAPOLIS IN 462501378, INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46250-1378

Mortgage

Document Number	0000125888
Date	Dec 16, 2019
Instrument	125888

Lender

Name	MIDFIRST BK
Type	Bank
Address	OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73118

Agreement

Amount	Amount on Record
Term	360 Months
Due	Dec 15, 2049

Interest

Rate Type	Fixed Rate
Rate	4%

Tax Assessment & Valuation

Source: Marion County assessment roll, as of March 16, 2026

Property Jurisdictions

Type	Name
State	Indiana
County	Marion County
County Subdivision	Lawrence Township
Consolidated City	Indianapolis City
Unified School District	Lawrence Township Metropolitan School District (PK - 12)

Tax Bill & Assessment History

Year	Tax Bill	Assessed Value	Assessed Market Value
2025		$364,500 Land $27,200 Building $337,300	$364,500 Land $27,200 Building $337,300
2024	$3,420.00 (+5.56%)
2023	$3,240.00 (+5.68%) Homeowner's exemption	$297,900 (+7.24%) Land $27,200 Building $270,700	$297,900 (+7.24%) Land $27,200 Building $270,700
2022	$3,066.00 Homeowner's exemption	$277,800 Land $27,200 Building $250,600	$277,800 Land $27,200 Building $250,600

Assessed value and assessed market value are set for property tax purposes and are not market price estimates.

Flood

FEMA maps place 5850 E 91st St in Zone X, an area of minimal flood risk.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, effective June 7, 2026 · OpenFEMA NFIP redacted claims and policies, as of September 2026

FEMA Flood Zone	Zone X minimal risk
Flood Insurance Requirement	Not required lenders may require it
Community Rating System	Class 8 (10% premium discount)
Nearby Flood Policies	1 in force

Values are read at the parcel center point; flood claims are located to the census block group, not this parcel; lenders make the official flood determination.

Wildfire

Wildfire risk around 5850 E 91st St is low, with less than a 0.01% annual chance of wildfire.

Source: USDA Forest Service Wildfire Risk to Communities (2nd edition), as of 2024

Wildfire Risk	Low lower than 96% of the US · lower than 73% of Indiana
Wildfire Likelihood	Under 0.01% annual chance
Exposure	None beyond ember reach

Values cover an area roughly 900 ft across, not the parcel itself; insurers use their own ratings.

Drinking Water

Source: EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System, as of September 2026

Water System	CITIZENS WATER - INDIANAPOLIS serves 880,345 people · EPA ID IN5249004
Water Source	Surface water
Last State Inspection	May 2024
Lead	3 ppb (2026) action level 15 ppb

Violations Reported to EPA

Water Quality	None last 10 years
Treatment and Procedure	None last 10 years
Monitoring and Reporting	None last 3 years

Results are for the whole water system, not water tested at this address; lead at the tap also depends on the building's own pipes.

Internet Providers

Source: FCC Broadband Data Collection, based on 270 locations within half a mile, as of December 31, 2025

Provider	Max Down / Up (Mbps)
Metronet Fiber	5,120 / 5,120
AT&T Fiber · DSL in parts of the area	5,000 / 5,000
Xfinity Cable	2,000 / 250
Verizon Fixed Wireless	1,000 / 75

May also be available: On-Ramp Indiana, T-Mobile.

Nearby Properties on E 91st St

Nearby Streets

Search Property Records by Address or Parcel Number

Search by:

By searching, you agree to: Terms • Privacy • Disclosures