537 Highgate Ave, Buffalo, NY 14215 Property Records

Erie County and Buffalo City property record for 537 Highgate Ave, Buffalo, NY 14215

Property Summary

Property TypeDuplex
Details3 bd · 2 ba · 1,610 sqft · built 1925
Lot Size0.086 acres (3,740 sqft)
OwnerIndividual Name on File
Last Sale$145,000 (Sep 2021)
Tax Bill$499 (2026)
Deeds & MortgagesSep 2021 Sale
Dec 2018 Line of Credit
+ 3 more
Flood ZoneZone X (minimal risk)
APN140200 79.66-4-9

Property Details

APN / Parcel Number

Primary APN140200 79.66-4-9
Alternative APNs
  • 02000796600004009000
  • 07959100

Interior

Bedrooms3 Beds
Full Baths2 Baths
Stories1 Story
Building Area1,610 sqft Total Area
1st Floor Area1,137 sqft
Upper Floors Area473 sqft

Exterior

Year BuiltBuilt 1925
Effective Year BuiltEffective 1925
Architectural StyleTraditional
Exterior MaterialAluminum/Vinyl
Lot Area3,740 sqft (0.086 acres)
Lot Dimensions110 ft deep x 34 ft wide
Garage TypeDetached
Garage Area400 sqft
Parking Spaces2 Parking Spaces

Utilities, Heating & Cooling

Heating SystemForced Air with A/C
Heating FuelGas
SewerMunicipal
Water SourceCommercial

Location & Zoning

Account Number07959100
Street Address537 HIGHGATE AVE
CityBUFFALO
StateNY
Zip14215-1203
Property CategoryResidential
Property TypeResidential > Multi-Unit > Duplex
Local Zoning CodeN-3R
Legal Description169. W ORLEANS
Legal SubdivisionHOLLAND LAND COMPANYS SURVEY
Legal Block4
Legal Lot Number9.000
JurisdictionERIE NY
Township / Civil DivisionBUFFALO
Census Block Group5
Census Block5003
Census Tract4300

Historic Designation

Source: NPS National Register of Historic Places, as of August 1, 2026

Historic DistrictWithin the Winspear Extension Historic District
listed 2024 · 494 contributing resources · NRIS 100009880

Federal listing alone does not restrict alterations; local historic district rules, which this data does not cover, may apply.

Owner

537 Highgate Ave, a duplex, is owned by an individual who bought it in September 2021.

Source: Erie County and Buffalo City records, as of October 20, 2026

Owner of RecordIndividual Name on File
Mailing Address3706 69TH ST, 4F, WOODSIDE, NY 11377-1739
Owner TypeIndividual

Owner names and exact recorded amounts are on file and can be viewed instantly on this page with a free 10-day trial.

Deeds, Mortgages & Sale History

DateDocument
Sep 2, 2021Warranty Deed, Transfer
CHICAGO TITLE COMPANY, CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE CO
Dec 14, 2018Deed of Trust, Mortgage · Line of Credit
EVANS BK NA
Oct 22, 2018Quit Claim Deed, Transfer
ATTORNEY ONLY
Mar 13, 2018Grant Deed, Transfer
NOT AVAILABLE
Mar 13, 2018Grant Deed, Transfer

Assessor's Deed Record

Deed NamesName on Deed
Last SaleSep 2, 2021 · Amount on File
Deed SaleSep 2, 2021 · Amount on File
Prior SaleMar 13, 2018 · Amount on File
Deed Document Number2021173515
Deed Book / Page11386 / 4853
Prior Transfer DateOct 18, 2018
Prior Transfer Doc0113361751
Record UpdatedOct 29, 2026

September 2021: Warranty Deed, Transfer

Document TypeWarranty Deed
JurisdictionERIE NY
Recording DateSep 2, 2021
Property Address537 HIGHGATE AVE, BUFFALO, NY 14215-1203
Document Number0113864853
Book / Page11386 / 4853
Instrument DateJul 19, 2021
Instrument2021173515
Transaction TypeTransfer
Record UpdatedNov 23, 2021
Title CompanyCHICAGO TITLE COMPANY, CHICAGO TITLE INSURANCE CO

Transaction

AmountAmount on Record
Tax$580.00
Amount AccuracyFull Amount Stated
Additional
  • Arm's Length

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

NameVerified Name
Address35 BUTTON BUSH CT, 35, AMHERST, NY 14228-3458

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

NameVerified Name
Address537 HIGHGATE AVE, BUFFALO, NY 14215-1203

December 2018: Deed of Trust, Mortgage

Document TypeDeed of Trust
JurisdictionERIE NY
Property Address537 HIGHGATE AVE, BUFFALO, NY 14215-1203
Document Number0138813400
Instrument DateDec 14, 2018
Transaction TypeMortgage
Record UpdatedJan 13, 2020
Title CompanyNOT AVAILABLE

Transaction

Additional
  • Multiple Parcels

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

NameVerified Name
RelationshipCompany
Address35 BUTTON BUSH CT AMHERST NY 142283458, AMHERST, NY 14228-3458

Mortgage

Document Number0138813400
DateDec 14, 2018
Book Page013881/003400
Lender
NameEVANS BK NA
TypeBank
AddressHAMBURG, NY 14075
Agreement
TypeLine of Credit
AmountAmount on Record
Interest
Rate TypeAdjustable Rate

October 2018: Quit Claim Deed, Transfer

Document TypeQuit Claim Deed
JurisdictionERIE NY
Recording DateOct 22, 2018
Property Address537 HIGHGATE AVE, BUFFALO, NY 14215-1203
Document Number0113361751
Book / Page011336 / 001751
Instrument DateOct 18, 2018
Transaction TypeTransfer
Record UpdatedNov 8, 2018
Title CompanyATTORNEY ONLY

Transaction

Tax$0.00
Additional
  • Quitclaim
  • Intrafamily Transfer

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

NameVerified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

NameVerified Name
RelationshipCompany
Address223 GREENHAVEN TER TONAWANDA NY 141505551, TONAWANDA, NY 14150-5551

March 2018: Grant Deed, Transfer

Document TypeGrant Deed
JurisdictionERIE NY
Recording DateMar 13, 2018
Property Address537 HIGHGATE AVE, BUFFALO, NY 14215-1203
Document Number0113267484
Book / Page011326 / 007484
Instrument DateMar 13, 2018
Transaction TypeTransfer
Record UpdatedNov 24, 2020
Title CompanyNOT AVAILABLE

Transaction

AmountAmount on Record
Tax$31.00
Amount AccuracyConfirmed
Additional
  • Arm's Length

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

NameVerified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

NameVerified Name
Address223 GREENHAVEN TER TONAWANDA NY 141505551, TONAWANDA, NY 14150-5551

March 2018: Grant Deed, Transfer

Document TypeGrant Deed
JurisdictionERIE NY
Recording DateMar 13, 2018
Property Address537 HIGHGATE AVE, BUFFALO, NY 14215-1203
Document Number0113267484
Book / Page011326 / 007484
Instrument DateJan 31, 2018
Transaction TypeTransfer
Record UpdatedJul 2, 2018

Transaction

AmountAmount on Record
Tax$31.00
Amount AccuracyConfirmed
Additional
  • Arm's Length
  • Multiple Parcels

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

NameVerified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

NameVerified Name
RelationshipCompany
Address223 GREENHAVEN TER TONAWANDA NY 141505551, TONAWANDA, NY 14150-5551

Tax Assessment & Valuation

The 2026 property tax bill for 537 Highgate Ave was $499, down 63.1% from the year before.

Source: Erie County and Buffalo City assessment roll, as of May 19, 2026

Property Jurisdictions

TypeName
StateNew York
CountyErie County
MunicipalityBuffalo City
Unified School DistrictBuffalo City School District (PK - 12)

Tax Bill & Assessment History

YearTax BillAssessed ValueAssessed Market Value
2026$499.00 (-63.12%)
2025$1,353.00 (+26.21%)$151,000 (+128.79%) Land $8,000 Building $143,000$151,000 (+40.7%) Land $8,000 Building $143,000
2024$1,072.00 (+213.45%)$66,000 (-) Land $4,700 Building $61,300$107,317 (+13.82%) Land $7,642 Building $99,675
2023$342.00$66,000 Land $4,700 Building $61,300$94,286 Land $6,714 Building $87,572

Assessed value and assessed market value are set for property tax purposes, not market price estimates; both are a fraction of this property's market value.

Flood

FEMA maps place 537 Highgate Ave in Zone X, an area of minimal flood risk, though there have been 1 flood claim nearby since 1979.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, effective November 20, 2024 · OpenFEMA NFIP redacted claims and policies, as of September 2026

FEMA Flood ZoneZone X
minimal risk
Flood Insurance RequirementNot required
lenders may require it
Nearby Flood Claims1 (1979)
Most Recent ClaimApr 1979 · rainfall accumulation

Values are read at the parcel center point; flood claims are located to the census block group, not this parcel; lenders make the official flood determination.

Wildfire

The area around 537 Highgate Ave has no burnable land within ember reach, so its wildfire risk is not rated.

Source: USDA Forest Service Wildfire Risk to Communities (2nd edition), as of 2024

Wildfire RiskNot rated
no burnable land within ember reach

Values cover an area roughly 900 ft across, not the parcel itself; insurers use their own ratings.

Drinking Water

Source: EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System, as of September 2026

Water SystemBUFFALO WATER AUTHORITY
serves 276,000 people · EPA ID NY1400422
Water SourceSurface water
Last State InspectionJul 2023
Lead3 ppb (2026)
action level 15 ppb

Violations Reported to EPA

Water QualityNone
last 10 years
Treatment and ProcedureNone
last 10 years
Monitoring and Reporting2
last 3 years

Results are for the whole water system, not water tested at this address; lead at the tap also depends on the building's own pipes.

Internet Providers

Source: FCC Broadband Data Collection, based on 1,460 locations within half a mile, as of December 31, 2025

ProviderMax Down / Up (Mbps)
Verizon
Fiber · Fixed Wireless in parts of the area
2,300 / 2,300
Spectrum
Cable · Fiber in parts of the area
1,000 / 1,000

Nearby Properties on Highgate Ave

Nearby Streets

Search Property Records by Address or Parcel Number