535 Mistletoe Ave, Youngstown, OH 44511 Property Records

Mahoning County property record for 535 Mistletoe Ave, Youngstown, OH 44511

Property Summary

Property Type	Single Family Home
Details	4 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,760 sqft · built 1925
Lot Size	0.149 acres (6,490 sqft)
Owner	Individual Name on File
Last Sale	$128,000 (Nov 2024)
Tax Bill	$217 (2025)
Deeds & Mortgages	Jan 2024 Sale & Mortgage Dec 2021 Foreclosure
Flood Zone	Zone X (minimal risk)
APN	`53-128-0-019.00-0`

Property Details

APN / Parcel Number

Primary APN	`53-128-0-019.00-0`
Alternative APN	`00197`

Interior

Bedrooms	4 Beds
Full Baths	1.5 Baths
Half Baths	1 Half Bath
Total Rooms	8 Rooms
Stories	2 Stories
Building Area	1,760 sqft Living Area
Gross Area	2,688 sqft
1st Floor Area	928 sqft
Upper Floors Area	832 sqft
Basement Area	928 sqft
Fireplaces	1 Fireplace
Fireplace	Fireplace

Exterior

Year Built	Built 1925
Effective Year Built	Effective 1925
Architectural Style	Conventional
Exterior Material	Brick
Construction Type	Brick
Lot Area	6,490 sqft (0.149 acres)
Lot Dimensions	130 ft deep x 50 ft wide
Parking Spaces	1 Parking Space
Patio Area	208 sqft

Utilities, Heating & Cooling

Cooling System	None
Heating System	Baseboard
Heating Fuel	Oil

Location & Zoning

Street Address	535 MISTLETOE AVE
City	YOUNGSTOWN
State	OH
Zip	44511-3269
Property Category	Residential
Property Type	Residential > Single Family > Home
Legal Description	LOT 23488 50 X 130 MISTLETOE
Legal Subdivision	MISTLETOE
Legal Lot Number	23488
Jurisdiction	MAHONING OH
Township / Civil Division	YOUNGSTOWN
Census Block Group	4
Census Block	4019
Census Tract	802400

Historic Designation

Source: NPS National Register of Historic Places, as of August 1, 2026

Historic District	Within the Mill Creek Park Historic District listed 2005 · 71 contributing resources · NRIS 05000178

Federal listing alone does not restrict alterations; local historic district rules, which this data does not cover, may apply.

Owner

535 Mistletoe Ave is owned and occupied by an individual who bought it in November 2024.

Source: Mahoning County records, as of February 9, 2026

Owner of Record	Individual Name on File
Mailing Address	535 MISTLETOE AVE, YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511-3269
Occupancy	Owner Occupied
Owner Type	Individual

Owner names and exact recorded amounts are on file and can be viewed instantly on this page with a free 10-day trial.

Deeds, Mortgages & Sale History

Date	Document
Jan 31, 2024	Warranty Deed, Transfer · Conventional Mortgage NOVUS HOME MORTGAGE
Dec 17, 2021	Sheriff's Deed, Foreclosure Foreclosure Auction

Assessor's Deed Record

Deed Names	Name on Deed
Last Sale	Nov 4, 2024 · Amount on File
Deed Sale	Nov 4, 2024 · Amount on File
Prior Sale	Jan 31, 2024 · Amount on File
Deed Document Number	202421296
Deed Book / Page	6650 / 1073
Prior Transfer Date	Oct 22, 2009
Prior Transfer Doc	005858/523
Record Updated	Sep 20, 2026

January 2024: Warranty Deed, Transfer

Document Type	Warranty Deed
Jurisdiction	MAHONING OH
Recording Date	Jan 31, 2024
Property Address	535 MISTLETOE AVE, YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511-3269
Document Number	006609/673
Book / Page	6609 / 673
Map Reference	VOL 13 PG 95
Instrument Date	Jan 26, 2024
Instrument	202400001838
Transaction Type	Transfer
Record Updated	Feb 12, 2024
Title Company	AMERICA TITLE, AMERICAN TITLE

Transaction

Amount	Amount on Record
Downpayment	Downpayment on Record
Loan-to-Value (LTV)	LTV on Record
Tax	$124.00
Amount Accuracy	Rounded by County
Additional	Arm's Length

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

Name	Verified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Relationship	Right of Survivorship
Address	531 AND 535 MISTLETOE AVENUE, YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511-3269

Mortgage

Document Number	202400001839
Date	Jan 31, 2024
Instrument	202400001839

Lender

Name	NOVUS HOME MORTGAGE
Type	Mortgage Company

Agreement

Type	Conventional Mortgage
Amount	Amount on Record
Term	361 Months
Due	Feb 1, 2054

December 2021: Sheriff's Deed, Foreclosure

Document Type	Sheriff's Deed
Jurisdiction	MAHONING OH
Recording Date	Dec 17, 2021
Property Address	535 MISTLETOE AVE, YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511-3269
Document Number	06491/1663
Book / Page	6491 / 1663
Map Reference	VOL 13 PG 95
Instrument Date	Dec 17, 2021
Instrument	202100035015
Transaction Type	Foreclosure
Record Updated	Jan 4, 2022

Transaction

Amount	Amount on Record
Tax	$42.40
Amount Accuracy	Full Amount Stated
Additional	Foreclosure Auction

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

Name	Verified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Address	79 ARLENE AVE, YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44512-2902

Tax Assessment & Valuation

The 2025 property tax bill for 535 Mistletoe Ave was $217, down 13.9% from the year before.

Source: Mahoning County assessment roll, as of February 9, 2026

Property Jurisdictions

Type	Name
State	Ohio
County	Mahoning County
Municipality	Youngstown City
Unified School District	Youngstown City School District (PK - 12)

Tax Bill & Assessment History

Year	Tax Bill	Assessed Value	Assessed Market Value
2025	$217.00 (-13.89%)	$5,120 (-) Land $420 Building $4,700	$14,640 Land $1,200 Building $13,440
2024	$252.00 (+0.8%)	$5,120 (-) Land $420 Building $4,700
2023	$250.00 (+8.23%)	$5,120 (+41.05%) Land $420 Building $4,700	$14,640 (+41.04%) Land $1,200 Building $13,440
2022	$231.00	$3,630 Land $410 Building $3,220	$10,380 Land $1,180 Building $9,200

Assessed value is set for property tax purposes, not a market price estimate; it is a fraction of this property's market value.

Flood

FEMA maps place 535 Mistletoe Ave in Zone X, an area of minimal flood risk.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, effective November 18, 2009

FEMA Flood Zone	Zone X minimal risk
Flood Insurance Requirement	Not required lenders may require it

Values are read at the parcel center point; lenders make the official flood determination.

Wildfire

Wildfire risk around 535 Mistletoe Ave is low, with less than a 0.01% annual chance of wildfire.

Source: USDA Forest Service Wildfire Risk to Communities (2nd edition), as of 2024

Wildfire Risk	Low lower than 99.1% of the US · lower than 96% of Ohio
Wildfire Likelihood	Under 0.01% annual chance
Exposure	None beyond ember reach

Values cover an area roughly 900 ft across, not the parcel itself; insurers use their own ratings.

Drinking Water

Source: EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System, as of September 2026

Water System	YOUNGSTOWN CITY PWS serves 130,530 people · EPA ID OH5002303
Water Source	Purchased surface water from MAHONING VALLEY SANITARY DISTRICT
Last State Inspection	Jun 2024
Lead	Under 1 ppb (2026) action level 15 ppb

Violations Reported to EPA

Water Quality	None last 10 years
Treatment and Procedure	None last 10 years
Monitoring and Reporting	1 last 3 years

Results are for the whole water system, not water tested at this address; lead at the tap also depends on the building's own pipes.

Internet Providers

Source: FCC Broadband Data Collection, based on 352 locations within half a mile, as of December 31, 2025

Provider	Max Down / Up (Mbps)
Spectrum Cable	1,000 / 1,000
Verizon Fixed Wireless	300 / 20
T-Mobile Fixed Wireless	100 / 20

May also be available: Armstrong, AT&T.

Nearby Properties on Mistletoe Ave

Nearby Streets

Search Property Records by Address or Parcel Number

Search by:

By searching, you agree to: Terms • Privacy • Disclosures