5291 William St, Lancaster, NY 14086 Property Records

Erie County and Lancaster Town property record for 5291 William St, Lancaster, NY 14086

Property Summary

Property TypeSingle Family Home
Details4 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,757 sqft · built 1958
Lot Size1.5 acres (65,340 sqft)
Owner2 Individual Names on File
Last Sale$234,900 (Dec 2019)
Tax Bill$6,830 (2026)
Deeds & MortgagesDec 2019 Sale & Mortgage
Dec 2019 Transfer
Flood ZoneZone X (minimal risk)
APN145289 116.03-2-21

Property Details

APN / Parcel Number

Primary APN145289 116.03-2-21
Alternative APN
  • 52891160300002021000

Interior

Bedrooms4 Beds
Full Baths1.5 Baths
Half Baths1 Half Bath
Stories1 Story
Building Area1,757 sqft Living Area
1st Floor Area1,004 sqft
Upper Floors Area753 sqft

Exterior

Year BuiltBuilt 1958
Effective Year BuiltEffective 1958
Architectural StyleCape Cod
Exterior MaterialAluminum/Vinyl
Lot Area65,340 sqft (1.5 acres)
Lot Width100 ft Width
Garage TypeAttached
Garage Area480 sqft
Parking Spaces2 Parking Spaces

Utilities, Heating & Cooling

Heating SystemForced Air with A/C
Heating FuelOil
SewerSeptic
Water SourceCommercial

Location & Zoning

Street Address5291 WILLIAM ST
CityLANCASTER
StateNY
Zip14086-9305
Property CategoryResidential
Property TypeResidential > Single Family > Home
Legal DescriptionSC R 1OO X 68O
Legal SubdivisionBUFFALO CREEK RESERVATION
Legal Block2
Legal Lot Number21.000
JurisdictionERIE NY
Township / Civil DivisionLANCASTER
Census Block Group4
Census Block4000
Census Tract14206

Owner

5291 William St is owned and occupied by two individuals who bought it in December 2019.

Source: Erie County and Lancaster Town records, as of October 20, 2026

Owner of Record2 Individual Names on File
Mailing Address5291 WILLIAM ST, LANCASTER, NY 14086-9305
OccupancyOwner Occupied
Owner TypeIndividual
VestingHusband and Wife

Owner names and exact recorded amounts are on file and can be viewed instantly on this page with a free 7–day trial.

Deeds, Mortgages & Sale History

DateDocument
Dec 18, 2019Warranty Deed, Transfer · FHA Mortgage
SUPREME LNDG
Dec 18, 2019Affidavit of Death, Transfer
NOT AVAILABLE

Assessor's Deed Record

Deed Names2 Names on Deed
Last SaleDec 18, 2019 · Amount on File
Deed SaleDec 18, 2019 · Amount on File
Deed Document Number20192019280520
Deed Book / Page11354 / 4101
Prior Transfer DateMay 29, 2014
Record UpdatedOct 29, 2026

December 2019: Warranty Deed, Transfer

Document TypeWarranty Deed
JurisdictionERIE NY
Recording DateDec 18, 2019
Property Address5291 WILLIAM ST, LANCASTER, NY 14086-9305
Document Number0113544101
Book / Page011354 / 004101
Instrument DateDec 6, 2019
Transaction TypeTransfer
Record UpdatedFeb 10, 2020
Title CompanyATTORNEY ONLY

Transaction

AmountAmount on Record
DownpaymentDownpayment on Record
Loan-to-Value (LTV)LTV on Record
Tax$235.00
Amount AccuracyConfirmed
Additional
  • Arm's Length

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

NameVerified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

NameVerified Name
RelationshipHusband and Wife
Address206 AURORA ST LANCASTER NY 140862716, LANCASTER, NY 14086-2716

Mortgage

Document Number139233846
DateDec 18, 2019
Book Page013923/003846
Lender
NameSUPREME LNDG
AddressDALLAS, TX 75254
Agreement
TypeFHA Mortgage
AmountAmount on Record
Term360 Months
DueDec 17, 2049

December 2019: Affidavit of Death, Transfer

Document TypeAffidavit of Death
JurisdictionERIE NY
Recording DateDec 18, 2019
Property Address5291 WILLIAM ST, LANCASTER, NY 14086-9305
Document Number0113544098
Book / Page011354 / 004098
Instrument DateDec 4, 2019
Transaction TypeTransfer
Record UpdatedFeb 7, 2020
Title CompanyNOT AVAILABLE

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

NameVerified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

NameVerified Name
Address5291 WILLIAM ST LANCASTER NY 140869305, LANCASTER, NY 14086-9305

Tax Assessment & Valuation

The 2026 property tax bill for 5291 William St was $6,830, up 11% from the year before.

Source: Erie County and Lancaster Town assessment roll, as of May 19, 2026

Property Jurisdictions

TypeName
StateNew York
CountyErie County
County SubdivisionLancaster Town
Unified School DistrictLancaster Central School District (PK - 12)

Tax Bill & Assessment History

YearTax BillAssessed ValueAssessed Market Value
2026$6,830.00 (+110.02%)
2025$3,252.00 (-50.44%)$235,000 (-) Land $55,000 Building $180,000$367,188 (+12.5%) Land $85,938 Building $281,250
2024$6,562.00$235,000 (-) Land $55,000 Building $180,000$326,400 (+4.18%) Land $76,391 Building $250,009
2023$235,000 Land $55,000 Building $180,000$313,300 Land $73,326 Building $239,974

Assessed value and assessed market value are set for property tax purposes and are not market price estimates.

Flood

FEMA maps place 5291 William St in Zone X, an area of minimal flood risk.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, effective November 20, 2024

FEMA Flood ZoneZone X
minimal risk
Flood Insurance RequirementNot required
lenders may require it

Values are read at the parcel center point; lenders make the official flood determination.

Wildfire

Wildfire risk around 5291 William St is low, with a 0.02% annual chance of wildfire.

Source: USDA Forest Service Wildfire Risk to Communities (2nd edition), as of 2024

Wildfire RiskLow
lower than 93% of the US · lower than 89% of New York
Wildfire Likelihood0.02% annual chance
ExposureDirect
burnable vegetation

Values cover an area roughly 900 ft across, not the parcel itself; insurers use their own ratings.

Drinking Water

Source: EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System, as of September 2026

Water SystemECWA LANCASTER
serves 29,018 people · EPA ID NY1400421
Water SourcePurchased surface water from ECWA DIRECT
Last State InspectionNov 2025
Lead10 ppb (2020–2022)
action level 15 ppb

Violations Reported to EPA

Water QualityNone
last 10 years
Treatment and ProcedureNone
last 10 years
Monitoring and ReportingNone
last 3 years

Results are for the whole water system, not water tested at this address; lead at the tap also depends on the building's own pipes.

Internet Providers

Source: FCC Broadband Data Collection, based on 182 locations within half a mile, as of December 31, 2025

ProviderMax Down / Up (Mbps)
Greenlight Networks
Fiber
8,000 / 8,000
Spectrum
Cable · Fiber in parts of the area
1,000 / 35
Verizon
Fixed Wireless
300 / 20
T-Mobile
Fixed Wireless
100 / 20

Nearby Properties on William St

Nearby Streets

Search Property Records by Address or Parcel Number