5185 Plaster Pt, Cayuga, NY 13034 Property Records

Cayuga County and Springport Town property record for 5185 Plaster Pt, Cayuga, NY 13034

Property Summary

Property Type	Single Family Home
Details	3 bd · 1 ba · 1,600 sqft · built 1960
Lot Size	0.333 acres (14,515 sqft)
Owner	2 Individual Names on Record
Last Sale	$850,000 (Sep 2025)
Tax Bill	$7,273 (2026)
Deeds & Mortgages	Sep 2025 Sale Sep 2025 Sale + 5 more
Flood Zone	Zone X (minimal risk)
APN	`055489 133.12-1-3`

Property Details

APN / Parcel Number

Primary APN	`055489 133.12-1-3`
Alternative APNs	`548913301200010030000000` `18066140`

Interior

Bedrooms	3 Beds
Full Baths	1 Bath
Stories	1 Story
Building Area	1,600 sqft Living Area
1st Floor Area	1,600 sqft

Exterior

Year Built	Built 1960
Effective Year Built	Effective 1990
Architectural Style	Ranch
Exterior Material	Aluminum/Vinyl
Foundation Type	Raised
Lot Area	14,515 sqft (0.333 acres)
Lot Dimensions	268 ft deep x 54 ft wide
View / Lot	Waterfront
Garage Type	Detached
Garage Area	528 sqft
Parking Spaces	2 Parking Spaces
Porch	Patio
Porch Area	288 sqft
Shed	1 Shed

Utilities, Heating & Cooling

Heating Fuel	Electric
Sewer	Municipal
Water Source	Commercial

Location & Zoning

Account Number	18066140
Street Address	5185 PLASTER PT
City	CAYUGA
State	NY
Zip	13034-3124
Property Category	Residential
Property Type	Residential > Single Family > Home
Local Zoning Code	01 - NOT Z
Legal Description	FORMERLY PARCEL 134-1-30 SMD 1019-41 56.62' LAKE FRONT
Legal Block	1
Legal Lot Number	3.000
Jurisdiction	CAYUGA NY
Township / Civil Division	SPRINGPORT
Census Block Group	2
Census Block	2042
Census Tract	41201

Owner

Source: Cayuga County and Springport Town records, as of September 23, 2026

Owner names and exact recorded amounts shown locked on this page are available instantly with a free trial.

Owner of Record	2 Individual Names on Record
Mailing Address	1145 BRENEMAN RD, MANHEIM, PA 17545-9624
Owner Type	Individual
Vesting	Tenants by the Entirety

Deeds, Mortgages & Sale History

Date	Document
Sep 29, 2025	Deed, Transfer
Sep 29, 2025	Warranty Deed, Transfer
Jan 4, 2023	Deed of Trust, Mortgage · Line of Credit CAYUGA LAKE NATIONAL BANK
Mar 11, 2021	Deed of Trust, Mortgage · Stand-Alone Refinance QUICKEN LOANS INC
May 4, 2020	Deed of Trust, Mortgage · Conventional Mortgage QUICKEN LNS
May 4, 2020	Deed of Trust, Mortgage · Conventional Mortgage QUICKEN LNS
Jan 22, 2019	Warranty Deed, Transfer · Conventional Mortgage QUICKEN LNS

Assessor's Deed Record

Deed Names	2 Names on Deed
Last Sale	Sep 29, 2025 · Amount on Record
Deed Sale	Sep 29, 2025 · Amount on Record
Prior Sale	Sep 29, 2025 · Amount on Record
Deed Document Number	2025238851
Deed Book / Page	4659 / 337
Record Updated	Oct 29, 2026

September 2025: Deed, Transfer

Document Type	Deed
Jurisdiction	CAYUGA NY
Recording Date	Sep 29, 2025
Property Address	5185 PLASTER PT, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124
Document Number	004659/337
Book / Page	4659 / 337
Instrument Date	Aug 29, 2025
Instrument	2025-238851
Transaction Type	Transfer
Record Updated	Oct 22, 2025

Transaction

Amount	Amount Recorded
Tax	$0.00
Amount Accuracy	Full Amount Stated
Additional	Arm's Length

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

Name	Verified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Relationship	Tenants by the Entirety

September 2025: Warranty Deed, Transfer

Document Type	Warranty Deed
Jurisdiction	CAYUGA NY
Recording Date	Sep 29, 2025
Property Address	5185 PLASTER PT, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124
Document Number	004659/328
Book / Page	4659 / 328
Instrument Date	Aug 29, 2025
Instrument	2025-238849
Transaction Type	Transfer
Record Updated	Oct 22, 2025

Transaction

Amount	Amount Recorded
Tax	$0.00
Amount Accuracy	Full Amount Stated
Additional	Arm's Length

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

Name	Verified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Investor	Possibly a Property Investor

January 2023: Deed of Trust, Mortgage

Document Type	Deed of Trust
Jurisdiction	CAYUGA NY
Property Address	5185 PLASTER PT, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124
Transaction Type	Mortgage
Record Updated	Jan 31, 2023

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name

Mortgage

Document Number	0004314/18
Date	Jan 4, 2023
Book Page	4314/18
Instrument	2023-219231

Lender

Name	CAYUGA LAKE NATIONAL BANK

Agreement

Type	Line of Credit
Amount	Amount Recorded
Term	289 Months
Due	Feb 1, 2047

Interest

Rate Type	Adjustable Rate

March 2021: Deed of Trust, Mortgage

Document Type	Deed of Trust
Jurisdiction	CAYUGA NY
Property Address	5185 PLASTER PT, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124
Transaction Type	Mortgage
Record Updated	Apr 6, 2021

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name

Mortgage

Document Number	0040110042
Date	Mar 11, 2021
Book Page	4011/42
Instrument	2021-202607

Lender

Name	QUICKEN LOANS INC
Type	Lending Institution

Agreement

Type	Stand-Alone Refinance
Amount	Amount Recorded
Term	241 Months
Due	Apr 1, 2041

May 2020: Deed of Trust, Mortgage

Document Type	Deed of Trust
Jurisdiction	CAYUGA NY
Property Address	5185 PLASTER PT, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124
Document Number	0039010326
Instrument Date	May 4, 2020
Transaction Type	Mortgage
Record Updated	Sep 1, 2020
Title Company	ATTORNEY ONLY

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Relationship	Husband and Wife
Address	5185 PLASTER PT CAYUGA NY 130343124, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124

Mortgage

Document Number	0039010326
Date	Jul 29, 2020
Book Page	003901/000326
Instrument	196882

Lender

Name	QUICKEN LNS
Type	Funding / Finance Company
Address	DETROIT, MI 48226-1906

Agreement

Type	Conventional Mortgage
Amount	Amount Recorded

May 2020: Deed of Trust, Mortgage

Document Type	Deed of Trust
Jurisdiction	CAYUGA NY
Property Address	5185 PLASTER PT, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124
Document Number	0039010302
Instrument Date	May 4, 2020
Transaction Type	Mortgage
Record Updated	Sep 1, 2020
Title Company	NOT AVAILABLE

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Relationship	Husband and Wife
Address	5185 PLASTER PT CAYUGA NY 130343124, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124

Mortgage

Document Number	0039010302
Date	Jul 29, 2020
Book Page	003901/000302
Instrument	196881

Lender

Name	QUICKEN LNS
Type	Funding / Finance Company
Address	DETROIT, MI 48226-1906

Agreement

Type	Conventional Mortgage
Amount	Amount Recorded
Term	360 Months
Due	Jul 28, 2050

January 2019: Warranty Deed, Transfer

Document Type	Warranty Deed
Jurisdiction	CAYUGA NY
Recording Date	Jan 22, 2019
Property Address	5185 PLASTER PT, CAYUGA, NY 13034-3124
Document Number	0036840193
Book / Page	003684 / 000193
Instrument Date	Dec 5, 2018
Instrument	184877
Transaction Type	Transfer
Record Updated	Jan 31, 2019
Title Company	STEWART TITLE, STEWART TITLE INSURANCE CO

Transaction

Amount	Amount Recorded
Downpayment	Downpayment on Record
Loan-to-Value (LTV)	LTV on Record
Tax	$1,200.00
Amount Accuracy	Confirmed
Additional	Arm's Length

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

Name	Verified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Relationship	Tenants by the Entirety
Address	975 AMBERLY PL COLUMBUS OH 432204101, COLUMBUS, OH 43220-4101

Mortgage

Document Number	36840197
Date	Jan 22, 2019
Book Page	003684/000197
Instrument	184878

Lender

Name	QUICKEN LNS
Type	Funding / Finance Company
Address	DETROIT, MI 48226-1906

Agreement

Type	Conventional Mortgage
Amount	Amount Recorded
Term	360 Months
Due	Jan 21, 2049

Tax Assessment & Valuation

Source: Cayuga County and Springport Town assessment roll, as of May 1, 2026

Property Jurisdictions

Type	Name
State	New York
County	Cayuga County
County Subdivision	Springport Town
Unified School District	Union Springs Central School District (PK - 12)

Tax Bill & Assessment History

Year	Tax Bill	Assessed Value	Assessed Market Value
2026	$7,273.00 (+5.62%)
2025	$6,886.00 (+5.34%)	$408,100 (+13.46%) Land $220,000 Building $188,100	$408,100 (+13.46%) Land $220,000 Building $188,100
2024	$6,537.00	$359,700 (+9.07%) Land $189,500 Building $170,200	$359,700 (+9.07%) Land $189,500 Building $170,200
2023		$329,800 Land $159,600 Building $170,200	$329,800 Land $159,600 Building $170,200

Assessed value is set for property tax purposes, not a market price estimate; it is a fraction of this property's market value.

Flood

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, effective April 30, 2025 · OpenFEMA NFIP redacted claims and policies, as of September 2026

FEMA Flood Zone	Zone X minimal risk
Nearest Special Flood Hazard Area	Zone AE, within 100 ft
Flood Insurance Requirement	Not required lenders may require it
Flood Insurance Cost	Premium on Record median of 12 policies
Nearby Flood Policies	12 in force
Nearby Flood Claims	1 (2015)
Claims Outside the SFHA	1 of 1
Most Recent Claim	May 2015 · rainfall accumulation

Values are read at the parcel center point; flood claims are located to the census block group, not this parcel; lenders make the official flood determination.

Wildfire

Source: USDA Forest Service Wildfire Risk to Communities (2nd edition), as of 2024

Wildfire Risk	Not rated no burnable land within ember reach

Values cover an area roughly 900 ft across, not the parcel itself; insurers use their own ratings.

Internet Providers

Source: FCC Broadband Data Collection, based on 32 locations within half a mile, as of December 31, 2025

Provider	Max Down / Up (Mbps)
Spectrum Cable	1,000 / 1,000
CBN Fixed Wireless · not low latency	100 / 100

May also be available: Verizon.

Cell Coverage

5G (outdoors only) and 4G LTE

Nearby Properties on Plaster Pt

Nearby Streets

Search Property Records by Address or Parcel Number

Search by:

By searching, you agree to: Terms • Privacy • Disclosures