2391 Old Rte 5, Chittenango, NY 13037 Property Records

Madison County and Sullivan Town property record for 2391 Old Rte 5, Chittenango, NY 13037

Property Summary

Property Type	Single Family Home
Details	5 bd · 2 ba · 3,235 sqft · built 1818
Lot Size	3.87 acres (168,577 sqft)
Owner	2 Individual Names on File
Last Sale	$375,000 (Jun 2025)
Tax Bill	$6,468 (2026)
Deeds & Mortgages	Apr 2022 Refinance Jun 2020 Mortgage
APN	`254889 42.-1-61`

Property Details

APN / Parcel Number

Primary APN	`254889 42.-1-61`
Alternative APNs	`488904200000010610000000` `3193`

Interior

Bedrooms	5 Beds
Full Baths	2 Baths
Half Baths	1 Half Bath
Stories	2 Stories
Building Area	3,235 sqft Living Area
1st Floor Area	1,783 sqft
2nd Floor Area	880 sqft
Upper Floors Area	572 sqft
Fireplaces	1 Fireplace
Fireplace	Fireplace

Exterior

Year Built	Built 1818
Effective Year Built	Effective 1818
Architectural Style	Traditional
Exterior Material	Wood
Lot Area	168,577 sqft (3.87 acres)
Garage Type	Detached
Garage Area	480 sqft
Parking Spaces	2 Parking Spaces

Exterior Amenities

Porch	Slab
Porch Area	108 sqft
Patio Area	252 sqft
Shed	1 Shed

Utilities, Heating & Cooling

Heating System	Hot Water
Heating Fuel	Gas
Sewer	Septic
Water Source	Well

Location & Zoning

Account Number	3193.
Street Address	2391 OLD ROUTE 5
City	CHITTENANGO
State	NY
Zip	13037-8728
Property Category	Residential
Property Type	Residential > Single Family > Home
Legal Block	1
Legal Lot Number	61.000
Jurisdiction	MADISON NY
Township / Civil Division	SULLIVAN
Census Block Group	1
Census Block	1002
Census Tract	30402

Owner

2391 Old Rte 5 is owned by two individuals who bought it in June 2025.

Source: Madison County and Sullivan Town records, as of October 20, 2026

Owner of Record	2 Individual Names on File
Mailing Address	51 OLE MUSKET LN, DANBURY, CT 06810-8215
Owner Type	Individual
Vesting	Tenants by the Entirety

Owner names and exact recorded amounts are on file and can be viewed instantly on this page with a free 10-day trial.

Deeds, Mortgages & Sale History

Date	Document
Apr 1, 2022	Warranty Deed, Transfer · Stand-Alone Refinance SENECA SAVINGS BANK
Jun 23, 2020	Quit Claim Deed, Transfer PREMIUM MTG

Assessor's Deed Record

Deed Names	2 Names on Deed
Last Sale	Jun 16, 2025 · Amount on File
Deed Sale	Jun 16, 2025 · Amount on File
Prior Sale	Apr 1, 2022 · Amount on File
Deed Document Number	20252745
Prior Transfer Date	May 26, 2020
Prior Transfer Doc	0000000996
Record Updated	Oct 29, 2026

April 2022: Warranty Deed, Transfer

Document Type	Warranty Deed
Jurisdiction	MADISON NY
Recording Date	Apr 1, 2022
Property Address	2391 OLD ROUTE 5, CHITTENANGO, NY 13037-8728
Document Number	0000000922
Instrument Date	Mar 17, 2022
Instrument	2022-1922
Transaction Type	Transfer
Record Updated	Apr 26, 2022

Transaction

Tax	$0.00
Amount Accuracy	No Consideration Stated
Additional	Arm's Length Multiple Parcels

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

Name	Verified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Relationship	Tenants by the Entirety
Address	6380 EVANS RD, CHITTENANGO, NY 13037-8789

Mortgage

Document Number	0000000923
Date	Apr 1, 2022
Instrument	2022-1923

Lender

Name	SENECA SAVINGS BANK

Agreement

Type	Stand-Alone Refinance
Amount	Amount on Record
Term	361 Months
Due	May 1, 2052

June 2020: Quit Claim Deed, Transfer

Document Type	Quit Claim Deed
Jurisdiction	MADISON NY
Recording Date	Jun 23, 2020
Property Address	2391 OLD ROUTE 5, CHITTENANGO, NY 13037-8728
Document Number	0000002996
Instrument Date	May 26, 2020
Instrument	2996
Transaction Type	Transfer
Record Updated	Jul 27, 2020
Title Company	SALT CITY ABSTRACT, SALT CITY ABS

Transaction

Tax	$0.00
Additional	Quitclaim

Transferred From (Grantor/Seller)

Name	Verified Name

Transferred To (Grantee/Buyer)

Name	Verified Name
Address	2391 OLD ROUTE 5 CHITTENANGO NY 130378728, CHITTENANGO, NY 13037-8728

Mortgage

Document Number	2997
Date	Jun 23, 2020
Instrument	2997

Lender

Name	PREMIUM MTG
Type	Mortgage Company
Address	ROCHESTER, NY 14618

Agreement

Amount	Amount on Record
Term	264 Months
Due	Jun 22, 2042

Interest

Rate Type	Fixed Rate

Tax Assessment & Valuation

The 2026 property tax bill for 2391 Old Rte 5 was $6,468, up 2.2% from the year before.

Source: Madison County and Sullivan Town assessment roll, as of April 17, 2026

Property Jurisdictions

Type	Name
State	New York
County	Madison County
County Subdivision	Sullivan Town
Unified School District	Chittenango Central School District (KG - 12)

Tax Bill & Assessment History

Year	Tax Bill	Assessed Value	Assessed Market Value
2026	$6,468.00 (+2.16%)
2025	$6,331.00	$161,100 Land $30,700 Building $130,400	$270,756 Land $51,597 Building $219,159
2023		$161,100 Land $30,700 Building $130,400	$233,478 Land $44,493 Building $188,985

Assessed value and assessed market value are set for property tax purposes, not market price estimates; both are a fraction of this property's market value.

Flood

FEMA has no flood map on file for 2391 Old Rte 5; there have been 4 flood claims nearby since 1995.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer · OpenFEMA NFIP redacted claims and policies, as of September 2026

FEMA Flood Zone	Not on file
Nearby Flood Policies	9 in force
Nearby Flood Claims	4 (1995–2017)
Claims Outside the SFHA	2 of 4
Most Recent Claim	Jul 2017 · other causes

Values are read at the parcel center point; flood claims are located to the census block group, not this parcel; lenders make the official flood determination.

Wildfire

Wildfire risk around 2391 Old Rte 5 is low, with a 0.01% annual chance of wildfire.

Source: USDA Forest Service Wildfire Risk to Communities (2nd edition), as of 2024

Wildfire Risk	Low lower than 80% of the US · above 54% of New York
Wildfire Likelihood	0.01% annual chance
Exposure	Direct burnable vegetation

Values cover an area roughly 900 ft across, not the parcel itself; insurers use their own ratings.

Internet Providers

Source: FCC Broadband Data Collection, based on 13 locations within half a mile, as of December 31, 2025

Provider	Max Down / Up (Mbps)
Spectrum Cable	1,000 / 1,000
Verizon Fixed Wireless	300 / 20

May also be available: T-Mobile.

Nearby Properties on Old Rte 5

Nearby Streets

Search Property Records by Address or Parcel Number

Search by:

By searching, you agree to: Terms • Privacy • Disclosures