Potter Hill Rd, Cincinnatus, NY Property Records

Cortland County and Taylor Town property records for 18 addresses on Potter Hill Rd, Cincinnatus, NY · Last verified October 2026

Potter Hill Rd Highlights

Properties 18
Median Sale Price $130,000
Deeds and Mortgages on File 14
Median Price per Sqft $108
Owner Occupied 39%
Median Annual Tax Bill $4,243
Median Year Built 1990
Median Ownership Tenure 12 years

Properties on Potter Hill Rd

Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4321 Potter Hill Rd

2 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,272 sqft built 1960 · 2.08 acres $65,400 Jan 1996 $4,243 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4331 Potter Hill Rd

3 bd · 1 ba · 1,488 sqft built 1840 · 4.4 acres $2,678 2026 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4343 Potter Hill Rd

4 bd · 2 ba · 1,664 sqft built 1900 · 133 acres $8,921 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4350 Potter Hill Rd

2 bd · 1 ba · 1,500 sqft built 2016 · 28.5 acres $150,000 Nov 2023 $4,943 2026 Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4380, #4382 Potter Hill Rd

3 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,956 sqft built 1975 · 2.6 acres $38,000 Apr 2008 $3,219 2025 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Apr 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4409 Potter Hill Rd

1 bd · 1 ba · 1,528 sqft built 1978 · 4.38 acres $50,000 Aug 2023 $4,243 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4428 Potter Hill Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,848 sqft built 2003 · 55.3 acres $225,000 Oct 2023 $7,208 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4563 Potter Hill Rd

0.229 acres $75,000 Jan 2023 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

4698 Potter Hill Rd

47.2 acres $2,149 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5593 Potter Hill Rd

26.5 acres $36,000 Dec 2009 $1,513 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5623 Potter Hill Rd

2 bd · 1,512 sqft built 1990 · 8.8 acres $34,500 May 2007 $2,153 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5732 Potter Hill Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,792 sqft built 2012 · 30.8 acres $105,000 Jul 2010 $5,528 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5745 Potter Hill Rd

54 acres $85,000 Dec 2014 $2,330 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5755 Potter Hill Rd

2 bd · 1 ba · 864 sqft built 1985 · 52 acres $4,803 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5757 Potter Hill Rd

1 bd · 1 ba · 720 sqft built 1988 · 5 acres $9,000 Oct 2004 $1,281 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5800 Potter Hill Rd

3 bd · 1.5 ba · 1,310 sqft built 1999 · 41.8 acres $300,000 Oct 2024 $7,685 2026 Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5894 Potter Hill Rd

2 bd · 1 ba · 1,200 sqft built 1995 · 1.96 acres $130,000 Sep 2022 $4,943 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5911 Potter Hill Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,568 sqft built 1998 · 1.2 acres $3,722 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied

Property Records in Nearby Streets