Plum Brook Rd, Great Valley, NY Property Records

Cattaraugus County, Great Valley Town and Ellicottville Town property records for 21 addresses on Plum Brook Rd, Great Valley, NY · Last verified October 2026

Plum Brook Rd Highlights

Properties 21
Median Sale Price $115,000
Deeds and Mortgages on File 19
Median Price per Sqft $86
Owner Occupied 29%
Median Annual Tax Bill $2,627
Median Year Built 1991
Median Ownership Tenure 7 years

Properties on Plum Brook Rd

Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5682 Plum Brook Rd

2 bd · 1 ba · 1,052 sqft built 1984 · 0.4 acres $1,640 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5691 Plum Brook Rd

2 bd · 2 ba · 2,422 sqft built 2008 · 7.06 acres $6,017 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5692 Plum Brook Rd

2 bd · 1 ba · 768 sqft built 2014 · 0.8 acres $2,955 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5698 Plum Brook Rd

2 bd · 1 ba · 660 sqft built 1972 · 0.739 acres $33,000 Nov 2000 $2,028 2026 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5714 Plum Brook Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,120 sqft built 1980 · 17.2 acres $85,000 May 2019 $2,449 2026 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5717 Plum Brook Rd

26.7 acres $90,000 Jan 2024 $1,302 2025 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5736 Plum Brook Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 2,016 sqft built 1991 · 4.9 acres $375,000 Nov 2025 $5,659 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5739 Plum Brook Rd

3 bd · 1 ba · 1,344 sqft built 2003 · 27.6 acres $171,500 Mar 2013 $5,586 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5764 Plum Brook Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,565 sqft built 2024 · 57.2 acres $300,000 Oct 2022 $7,115 2026 Assessor + 5 Documents Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5779 Plum Brook Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,596 sqft built 1985 · 11.6 acres $115,000 Jun 2019 $2,627 2026 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5838 Plum Brook Rd

$3,168 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5842 Plum Brook Rd

built 1988 · 3.2 acres $498 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5854 Plum Brook Rd

5 acres $550 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5886 Plum Brook Rd

460 sqft built 1970 · 154 acres $40,000 Jul 2016 $6,364 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5901 Plum Brook Rd

2 bd · 600 sqft built 1970 · 123 acres $2,657 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5923 Plum Brook Rd

8.45 acres $115,000 May 2023 $1,511 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5942 Plum Brook Rd

23.3 acres $10,000 Mar 2025 $1,525 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5956 Plum Brook Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 2,000 sqft built 2006 · 6.65 acres $5,735 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5967 Plum Brook Rd

3 bd · 2 ba · 1,200 sqft built 2002 · 6 acres $1,176 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5972 Plum Brook Rd

4 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,512 sqft built 2013 · 7.95 acres $190,000 Oct 2009 $12,337 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

5989 Plum Brook Rd

5.55 acres $584 2026 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File

Property Records in Nearby Streets