Penny St, West Islip, NY Property Records

Suffolk County and Islip Town property records for 38 addresses on Penny St, West Islip, NY · Last verified October 2026

Penny St Highlights

Properties 38
Median Sale Price $575,000
Deeds and Mortgages on File 37
Median Price per Sqft $236
Owner Occupied 89%
Median Annual Tax Bill $11,929
Median Year Built 1965
Median Ownership Tenure 12 years

Properties on Penny St

Owner names are on file and can be viewed instantly on this page with a free 7–day trial.

Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

3 Penny St

2,262 sqft built 1954 · 0.319 acres $534,500 Aug 2018 $16,340 2024 Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

8 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

11 Penny St

1,250 sqft built 1965 · 0.25 acres $380,000 Dec 2021 $12,262 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

12 Penny St

0.25 acres $300,000 Feb 2002 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

15 Penny St

3,633 sqft built 1961 · 0.25 acres $860,000 Dec 2021 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

16 Penny St

0.51 acres $350,000 Feb 2002 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

19 Penny St

1,190 sqft built 1965 · 0.25 acres $390,000 Aug 2019 Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

23 Penny St

1,791 sqft built 1965 · 0.25 acres $415,000 Nov 2018 $13,982 2024 Assessor + 4 Documents Updated Sep 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

24 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

27 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

28 Penny St

0.25 acres $385,000 Jun 2010 $11,929 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

31 Penny St

0.25 acres $97,500 Mar 1996 $9,251 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

32 Penny St

0.25 acres $287,500 Aug 2003 $10,263 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

35 Penny St

0.25 acres $123,000 Mar 1994 $10,570 2024 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

36 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

39 Penny St

0.25 acres $735,000 Jun 2025 $14,411 2024 Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

40 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

55 Penny St

0.25 acres $272,000 Jan 2017 $10,126 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Sep 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

56 Penny St

2,349 sqft built 2005 · 0.25 acres $490,000 Mar 2017 $17,755 2024 Assessor + 4 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

58 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

59 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

61 Penny St

0.25 acres $315,000 Apr 2007 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

62 Penny St

0.25 acres $575,000 Nov 2024 $9,890 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

65 Penny St

0.25 acres $250,000 Sep 2001 $13,039 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

66 Penny St

0.25 acres $251,500 Jan 2011 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

69 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

70 Penny St

0.25 acres $665,000 Feb 2023 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

73 Penny St

0.25 acres $400,000 Dec 2015 $11,917 2024 Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

74 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

77 Penny St

0.25 acres $191,000 Jan 2000 $11,220 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

78 Penny St

0.25 acres $255,000 Jun 2003 $9,445 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

81 Penny St

0.25 acres $10,804 2024 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

85 Penny St

0.25 acres Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

86 Penny St

0.51 acres Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

87 Penny St

0.25 acres $450,000 Sep 2014 $12,872 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

90 Penny St

0.25 acres $120,000 Aug 1999 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

91 Penny St

2,163 sqft built 1979 · 0.26 acres $400,000 Jan 2016 $14,565 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

94 Penny St

0.31 acres $236,900 Jul 2001 $12,206 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied

Property Records in Nearby Streets