Suffolk County and Islip Town property records for 38 addresses on Penny St, West Islip, NY · Last verified October 2026
| Properties | 38 |
|---|---|
| Median Sale Price | $575,000 |
| Deeds and Mortgages on File | 37 |
| Median Price per Sqft | $236 |
| Owner Occupied | 89% |
| Median Annual Tax Bill | $11,929 |
| Median Year Built | 1965 |
| Median Ownership Tenure | 12 years |
Owner names are on file and can be viewed instantly on this page with a free 7–day trial.
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
3 Penny St |
2,262 sqft built 1954 · 0.319 acres | $534,500 Aug 2018 | $16,340 2024 | Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
8 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
11 Penny St |
1,250 sqft built 1965 · 0.25 acres | $380,000 Dec 2021 | $12,262 2024 | Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
12 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $300,000 Feb 2002 | Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
15 Penny St |
3,633 sqft built 1961 · 0.25 acres | $860,000 Dec 2021 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
16 Penny St |
0.51 acres | $350,000 Feb 2002 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
19 Penny St |
1,190 sqft built 1965 · 0.25 acres | $390,000 Aug 2019 | Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
23 Penny St |
1,791 sqft built 1965 · 0.25 acres | $415,000 Nov 2018 | $13,982 2024 | Assessor + 4 Documents Updated Sep 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
24 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
27 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
28 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $385,000 Jun 2010 | $11,929 2024 | Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
31 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $97,500 Mar 1996 | $9,251 2024 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
32 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $287,500 Aug 2003 | $10,263 2024 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
35 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $123,000 Mar 1994 | $10,570 2024 | Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
36 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor Updated Oct 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
39 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $735,000 Jun 2025 | $14,411 2024 | Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
40 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | Owner on File |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
55 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $272,000 Jan 2017 | $10,126 2024 | Assessor + 1 Document Updated Sep 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
56 Penny St |
2,349 sqft built 2005 · 0.25 acres | $490,000 Mar 2017 | $17,755 2024 | Assessor + 4 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
58 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
59 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
61 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $315,000 Apr 2007 | Assessor Updated Oct 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
62 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $575,000 Nov 2024 | $9,890 2024 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
65 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $250,000 Sep 2001 | $13,039 2024 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
66 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $251,500 Jan 2011 | Assessor Updated Oct 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
69 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | Owner on File |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
70 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $665,000 Feb 2023 | Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
73 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $400,000 Dec 2015 | $11,917 2024 | Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
74 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor Updated Oct 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
77 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $191,000 Jan 2000 | $11,220 2024 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
78 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $255,000 Jun 2003 | $9,445 2024 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
81 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $10,804 2024 | Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
85 Penny St |
0.25 acres | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
86 Penny St |
0.51 acres | Assessor Updated Oct 2026 | Owner on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
87 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $450,000 Sep 2014 | $12,872 2024 | Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
90 Penny St |
0.25 acres | $120,000 Aug 1999 | Assessor Updated Oct 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
91 Penny St |
2,163 sqft built 1979 · 0.26 acres | $400,000 Jan 2016 | $14,565 2024 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |
| Address | Details | Last Sale | Tax Bill | Records | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
94 Penny St |
0.31 acres | $236,900 Jul 2001 | $12,206 2024 | Assessor Updated Aug 2026 | 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied |