May St, Bay Shore, NY Property Records

Suffolk County, Islip Town and Huntington Town property records for 12 addresses on May St, Bay Shore, NY · Last verified October 2026

May St Highlights

Properties 12
Median Sale Price $316,940
Deeds and Mortgages on File 11
Average Living Area 1,512 sq ft
Owner Occupied 67%
Median Annual Tax Bill $9,954
Median Year Built 1957
Median Ownership Tenure 10 years

Properties on May St

Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

6 May St

1,275 sqft built 1955 · 0.11 acres $390,000 May 2020 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

7 May St

0.23 acres $316,940 May 2006 $8,905 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

8 May St

0.23 acres $305,000 Sep 2007 $9,681 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

9 May St

0.16 acres $236,000 May 2023 $10,226 2024 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

10 May St

1,186 sqft built 1957 · 0.11 acres $9,802 2024 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

11 May St

2,076 sqft built 1960 · 0.18 acres $400,000 Apr 2022 $13,655 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

14 May St

0.18 acres $95,000 Jun 1994 $13,787 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

15 May St

0.11 acres $130,000 Oct 2012 Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

16 May St

0.18 acres $10,659 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

19 May St

0.119 acres $468,801 Jul 2026 $9,681 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

20 May St

0.28 acres Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

22 May St

0.139 acres $269,500 Aug 2016 $9,954 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied