Suffolk County and Islip Town property records for 17 addresses on Benjamin St, Bay Shore, NY · Last verified October 2026
| Properties | 17 |
|---|---|
| Median Sale Price | $470,000 |
| Deeds and Mortgages on File | 21 |
| Average Living Area | 1,678 sq ft |
| Owner Occupied | 76% |
| Median Annual Tax Bill | $9,257 |
| Median Year Built | 1932 |
| Median Ownership Tenure | 10 years |
Owner names and prior sale amounts shown locked below are available instantly with a free trial.
2,676 sqft · built 1937 · 0.169 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $212,000Jul 2016 | $12,9592024 | Amount on Record Jul 2015 | 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied | Assessor + 3 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026 |
0.11 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $189,000May 2013 | Owner on Record Owner Occupied | Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Oct 2026 |
0.1 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owner on Record Owner Occupied | AssessorUpdated Aug 2026 |
0.15 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $480,000Aug 2023 | Amount on Record — | Owner on Record | Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026 |
0.16 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $325,000Jan 2006 | $8,8632024 | Amount on Record Jun 2005 | Owner on Record Owner Occupied | AssessorUpdated Aug 2026 |
0.16 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $7,8912024 | 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied | AssessorUpdated Oct 2026 |
0.15 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owner on Record Owner Occupied | Assessor + 3 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026 |
1,016 sqft · built 1930 · 0.23 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owner on Record Owner Occupied | Assessor + 3 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026 |
0.2 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $185,000Aug 2013 | $9,8442024 | Owner on Record Owner Occupied | Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Aug 2026 |
0.119 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $670,000Feb 2025 | Amount on Record Jun 2021 | Owner on Record | Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Oct 2026 |
0.11 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $470,000Jul 2023 | Amount on Record Jan 2003 | 2 Owners on Record | Assessor + 2 DocumentsUpdated Aug 2026 |
0.11 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Owner on Record Owner Occupied | AssessorUpdated Oct 2026 |
0.169 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $635,000Mar 2025 | Amount on Record Nov 2024 | 2 Owners on Record | Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Sep 2026 |
1,344 sqft · built 1932 · 0.11 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $375,000Oct 2020 | $9,2572024 | Amount on Record Apr 2017 | Owner on Record Owner Occupied | Assessor + 3 DocumentsUpdated Sep 2026 |
0.169 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $87,000Dec 1994 | 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied | AssessorUpdated Aug 2026 |
0.1 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $194,000Jan 2011 | $9,3902024 | Amount on Record Mar 2010 | 2 Owners on Record Owner Occupied | Assessor + 1 DocumentUpdated Sep 2026 |
0.1 acres
| Last Sale | Tax Bill | Prior Sale | Owner | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $171,000Jan 2010 | $5,5122024 | Amount on Record Jun 2002 | Owner on Record Owner Occupied | AssessorUpdated Aug 2026 |