Bay 5th St, West Islip, NY Property Records

Suffolk County and Islip Town property records for 25 addresses on Bay 5th St, West Islip, NY · Last verified October 2026

Bay 5th St Highlights

Properties 25
Median Sale Price $780,000
Deeds and Mortgages on File 22
Median Price per Sqft $314
Owner Occupied 88%
Median Annual Tax Bill $16,243
Median Year Built 1957
Median Ownership Tenure 9 years

Properties on Bay 5th St

Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

500 Bay 5th St

0.76 acres Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

501 Bay 5th St

0.48 acres $2,390,000 Feb 2026 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

503 Bay 5th St

0.25 acres $495,000 Sep 2011 $16,200 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

504 Bay 5th St

2,396 sqft built 1954 · 0.25 acres $597,500 Oct 2017 $20,447 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

505 Bay 5th St

2,490 sqft built 1957 · 0.25 acres $808,000 Jun 2022 $16,114 2024 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

506 Bay 5th St

0.25 acres $537,000 Jul 2002 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

507 Bay 5th St

2,562 sqft built 1957 · 0.25 acres — Jan 2019 $16,243 2024 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

508 Bay 5th St

0.25 acres Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

509 Bay 5th St

1,801 sqft built 1955 · 0.25 acres $635,000 Jan 2019 $17,044 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

511 Bay 5th St

2,196 sqft built 1956 · 0.25 acres $415,000 Apr 2021 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

512 Bay 5th St

2,464 sqft built 1965 · 0.33 acres $775,000 Dec 2021 $33,494 2024 Assessor + 2 Documents Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

516 Bay 5th St

0.33 acres $325,000 Jan 1997 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

525 Bay 5th St

2,648 sqft built 1957 · 0.269 acres $535,000 Aug 2015 $16,791 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Sep 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

527 Bay 5th St

1,863 sqft built 1955 · 0.26 acres $513,110 Jun 2016 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

530 Bay 5th St

0.23 acres $505,000 Jul 2010 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

533 Bay 5th St

0.1 acres Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

536 Bay 5th St

0.089 acres — Jul 2014 $9,871 2024 Assessor + 3 Documents Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

537 Bay 5th St

0.23 acres $780,000 Oct 2025 $17,605 2024 Assessor + 1 Document Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

540 Bay 5th St

1,024 sqft built 1964 · 0.089 acres Assessor + 1 Document Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

543 Bay 5th St

0.239 acres $810,000 Mar 2025 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

549 Bay 5th St

0.089 acres $11,417 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

550 Bay 5th St

0.11 acres Assessor Updated Oct 2026 Owner on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

557 Bay 5th St

0.11 acres Assessor Updated Oct 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

560 Bay 5th St

0.11 acres $500,000 Jun 2014 $14,935 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied
Address Details Last Sale Tax Bill Records Owner

563 Bay 5th St

0.11 acres $375,000 Jun 2014 $11,417 2024 Assessor Updated Aug 2026 2 Owners on File Owner Occupied

Property Records in Nearby Streets